Fair and Reasonable Update: Court, Day 1
By Nicole McKee, COLFO- 5th May, 2020 May 5, 2020, 12:25 PM
- 0 Comments
- Bookmark
I’m now out of our first day of hearings and a “Zoom” meeting with our lawyers. Of course a result is impossible to predict, and I make this observation as a non-lawyer, but it appeared Justice Cooke really engaged on the arguments we made.
The Judge certainly made our QC earn his fee! The whole day was full of detailed legal questions and clarifications from the Judge as Jack Hodder QC presented our case. It wasn’t until 4:30pm that we finished our case and the Crown began its defence.
The Court spent most of the day discussing the issue of compensation and whether Stuart Nash had the ability to provide compensation for banned ammunition.
Our argument is largely that there is a common law right to compensation when you are deprived of your property rights - an important issue that goes well beyond the question of compensation for ammunition.
There was a detailed discussion on the case law for the principle - our case is that it does not matter that possession was criminalised (rather than in most of the cases, which are about Government confiscating property), compensation must still be made. If you are interested you can read our written submissions here.
“Our argument is largely that there is a common law right to compensation when you a deprived of your property rights - an important issue that goes well beyond the question of compensation for ammunition.”
The Judge was also looking at the intent of Parliament closely - what did Parliament intend to ban, how much decision-making power did MPs intended to give to the Minister, and whether Parliament considered the issue of compensation.
As Parliament is the ultimate decision-maker, what MPs were looking at when they gave the Police Minister the ability to prohibit certain types of ammunition is key.
This afternoon the Court looked at the detail of the types of ammunition that were banned - focusing on enhanced penetration and tracer. There is a lot of detail, including evidence from our expert witnesses, in our submissions. What is clear is that the Police Minister did not seek to make a decision that would make us any safer.
Stuff and Radio NZ had journalists in court/watching via private video link. You can read the Stuff coverage here, and listen to the Radio NZ story here.
Once the Crown’s lawyers have finished presenting their oral arguments, our lawyers get a right of reply.
I’ll update you again tonight.
Thank you again for making this effort possible.
Nicole McKee
Spokesperson
Fair and Reasonable Campaign
Fair and Reasonable
PO Box 24020,
Manners Street,
Wellington 6142,
New Zealand
Keep up with Fair and Reasonable on Facebook.
More in Associations
Fair and Reasonable Update: Court, Day 2
By Nicole McKee, COLFO- 6th May, 2020
- 2 Comments
A shorter day that was focused on the Crown’s response, and the reply from our QC Jack Hodder...
GAC Update: Safe domestic travel should be considered at Level 2
By NZ Game Animal Council- 4th May, 2020
- 0 Comments
The New Zealand Professional Hunting Guides Association and Game Animal Council are joining...
More from NZGUNS
SOG SEAL XR Knife
By Nik Maxwell- 31st Jul, 2020
- 2 Comments
If you hunt, shoot, or spend any amount of time in the outdoors, you’ll no doubt own a knife...
Metallic Reloading 101 - Part 5: Setting & checking projectile seating depth
By Craig Maylam- 18th Jul, 2020
- 0 Comments
The most frequently asked question by new centrefire cartridge reloaders is how to determine...
Winter Stags Fiordland
By Adam McGrath- 11th Aug, 2020
- 1 Comment
I had spent the entire last cruise of my shift dreaming of being in the hills and imagining chasing winter red stags in Fiordland...
Popular: Associations
The Royal Commission of Inquiry - No Accountability
By Phil Cregeen, SSANZ- 2nd Jan, 2021
- 2 Comments
Fair and Reasonable Update: Royal Commission delivers report tomorrow
By Michael Dowling, COLFO- 25th Nov, 2020
- 0 Comments
Fair and Reasonable Update: The Government made a key concession this week
By Michael Dowling, COLFO- 7th Dec, 2020
- 0 Comments
Fair and Reasonable Update: Royal Commission report - and yes the Police let us down
By Michael Dowling, COLFO- 9th Dec, 2020
- 0 Comments
Comments