Subscribe to NZGUNS

Register and subscribe to view unlimited premium content.

Fair and Reasonable Update: Review at 12 months, and the plan ahead

By Michael Dowling, COLFO

A little over 12 months ago, we pulled together the ‘Fair and Reasonable’ campaign to fight back against the Government’s vilification of Licenced Firearms Owners, and our way of life.


Last week, we received the High Court decision on costs in relation to our judicial review of Stuart Nash’s decision on compensation for banned ammunition.


In it, the High Court Judge reduced the costs awarded - he reiterated what had been said in the June judgment: that, in general and at common law, New Zealanders have a right to compensation when government abrogates property rights.


Despite our narrow loss (which is why we’re currently appealing to the Court of Appeal) Cooke J’s decision on costs acknowledges that our case was brought in the public interest.


“We must continue to fight for our rights, including to property, and compensation when the state takes it from us.”


He said that the “Court’s judgment vindicated the (property compensation) right notwithstanding that the claims were unsuccessful.


The Judge said individuals and groups seeking to uphold rights should not be dissuaded from taking court action by cost awards.


Questions of legality, and legal principle, should be central when the government is responding to a crisis or emergency. Litigation challenging decisions made in such circumstances is not to be discouraged by costs awards, particularly if it properly concerns the protection of individual rights... These factors should be taken into account in deciding costs in this case.


We must continue to fight for our rights, including to property, and compensation when the state takes it from us. As well as the appeal (which we’ll keep you updated on) here’s our summary of the year that was:



Thanks again for you, and all the others like you, who make this work possible.


Michael Dowling


Council of Licenced Firearms Owners

(on behalf of the Fair and Reasonable Campaign)


Keep up with Fair and Reasonable on Facebook.


Please Sign in or Register to comment

More in Associations

community tahr

NZ Tahr Foundation Update: Disappointing Tahr decision amid concerns over process

By Willie Duley, NZ Tahr Foundation

The NZ Tahr Foundation is very disappointed at DOC’s decision...

conservation hunting sika

CNISF Update: Conservation Week and other news

By Central North Island Sika Foundation

Hunting is conservation and with our projects, we work hard to ensure the Sika herd thrives in a sustainable environment...

More from NZGUNS

community conservation hunting

GAC Update: Hunters to choose their champion for Bird of the Year

By Game Animal Council

The Game Animal Council (GAC), the NZ Deerstalkers Association (NZDA) and Hunters for Conservation...

community politics

Election Result a Victory for MMP

By Rupert Pye

Somehow the magnitude of the Labour Party victory in Saturday’s election fuelled some ardent critics of MMP into a fury...

Winter Stags Fiordland

By Adam McGrath

I had spent the entire last cruise of my shift dreaming of being in the hills and imagining chasing winter red stags in Fiordland...

A new version of this app/site is available. Click here to update.